Insurance and Liability for Community Gardens and Urban Farms: What You Need to Know

Who is responsible when someone gets hurt
When a visitor trips, a volunteer is injured or a tool damages a neighbor’s fence, the claim usually goes to whoever ran the activity or controlled the land. Several parties may be involved, and each has different protection.
| Who | What the law does | What usually remains |
|---|---|---|
| Unpaid volunteer | The federal Volunteer Protection Act can limit personal liability if conditions are met. | Harm caused by willful or criminal misconduct, gross negligence or reckless conduct is not covered. |
| The garden or farm organization | The Act does not affect an organization’s liability. | The organization can still be sued, and state law may treat it like an employer. |
| Landowner who lends land | Some states limit liability for gardening use (Texas, Oregon). | Protection can depend on a sign or on not charging fees; it is state-specific. |
| Paid worker | State workers’ compensation law usually applies. | Misclassifying a worker as a volunteer can bring penalties. |
| Visitor or customer | No special federal shield for gardens. | Ordinary negligence rules of your state apply. |
The rest of this guide follows that table. For the volunteer questions in detail, see our guide on volunteer liability in community gardens.
What the federal Volunteer Protection Act does
The Volunteer Protection Act of 1997 (42 U.S.C. §§ 14501–14505) protects a volunteer from personal liability for harm caused while volunteering, but only when four conditions are all met:
- The volunteer acted within the scope of their responsibilities for the organization.
- The volunteer had any license, certificate or authorization that the state requires.
- The harm was not caused by willful or criminal misconduct, gross negligence or reckless misconduct.
- The harm was not caused by driving a vehicle (or operating a boat or aircraft) that the state requires to be licensed or insured.
The Act has limits that matter for planning. It does not affect the liability of the nonprofit organization itself, and it does not stop the organization from suing its own volunteer. States may add conditions, such as requiring volunteer training or a source of financial recovery, and may make organizations liable for their volunteers the way an employer would be. The Act defines a “volunteer” as someone who receives no more than $500 a year in compensation; reimbursement of actual expenses does not count.
Lending or leasing land for a garden
Landowners worry that allowing a garden makes them responsible for everything that happens on it. Some states address this directly, and the rules differ.
| State | What the law says | Conditions to check |
|---|---|---|
| Texas, Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 75.0025 (since Sept. 1, 2015) | An owner, lessee or occupant who lets people use land as a community garden does not, by that permission, guarantee the premises are safe or take responsibility for injuries, property damage or third-party acts. The attractive nuisance doctrine does not apply. | Does not cover willful or wanton acts or gross negligence. A visible sign with the wording the statute sets must be posted and kept readable. |
| Oregon, ORS 105.688 | Extends the state’s recreational-use immunities to land used for gardening, and to paths leading to it. | The immunities do not apply if the owner charges more than $25 per year for use of the land for gardening. In general, charging for permission to use land removes the protection. |
These two are examples, not a national rule. Many states have recreational-use laws with their own conditions, and plot fees can change the result, so ask a lawyer how your state’s law treats a garden. If the land is city-owned, the city’s agreement usually says who must carry insurance; see adopt-a-lot programs and garden licenses.
Volunteers and workers’ compensation
Workers’ compensation is state law, and volunteers are usually outside it. The Alaska Department of Labor (page updated November 10, 2025) says volunteers generally lack a contract of hire, so they are not covered and cannot file a claim. It also says status is decided case by case: recurring stipends, housing, regular meal vouchers or fixed schedules can make someone an employee. Alaska has no law either permitting or requiring nonprofits to buy workers’ compensation for volunteers; the options it lists are an endorsement to an existing policy or an accident and medical plan. Other states differ, so call your state workers’ compensation board. For paid help, see employment laws.
Two sample documents are kept on our site as PDFs: the Model Farm Volunteer Waiver and Guide (Version 1, seven pages, by A. Bryan Endres, Megan Galey and Rachel Armstrong) and the Arroyo Seco Network of Time Banks Neighborhood Fruit Harvest Agreement (two pages). Treat both as examples to adapt with a lawyer, not as ready-made forms.
Types of insurance and what each is for
Policy names and terms vary by insurer. This table shows the usual purpose of each type; it is general, so read the actual policy.
| Type | Usually meant for | Ask the insurer |
|---|---|---|
| General liability | Injury or property damage claims by people who are not your workers, such as visitors or neighbors. | Are volunteers covered, or excluded? Are events and farm stands covered? |
| Volunteer accident | Medical costs of an injured volunteer, usually regardless of fault, up to the policy limit. | What are the limits, and does it pay on top of the volunteer’s own health insurance? |
| Workers’ compensation | Work injuries of employees, as required by your state. | Can volunteers be added where your state allows it? |
| Product liability | Claims that food you sold made someone ill. | Does it cover your products (eggs, honey, cottage food, produce)? |
| Property | Damage to your structures, tools and equipment. | Does it cover structures on land you do not own? |
| Umbrella | Extra limits on top of a liability policy. | Which underlying policies must you have first? |
The Alaska Division of Insurance, as quoted on the state labor page, notes that some general liability policies exclude volunteers. That is why the first question to any insurer should be about volunteers. If you sell food, also read our food safety guide and the cottage food laws for your state.
Where to start
- Who is on site and who owns the land?List volunteers, paid workers, visitors and the owner. If someone else owns the land, read their agreement for insurance terms. Go to step 2.
- Do you pay anyone, or give stipends, housing or meals?Yes: ask your state labor agency whether they are employees. No: go to step 3.
- Are you a nonprofit, an LLC or an informal group?Informal groups have no separate entity to hold the policy; see our nonprofit guide. Go to step 4.
- Do you sell food or host events?Yes: ask about product liability and event coverage. No: go to step 5.
- Have you asked at least two insurers the same written questions?No: do that and compare exclusions, not just price. Yes: choose, and keep the policy documents.
Questions to ask an insurer
- Are volunteers covered, and for what kinds of injury?
- Are events, workshops, farm stands and donated food covered?
- Does the policy cover land we lease or borrow, and who must be listed as an additional insured?
- Are hens, bees, tools or vehicles excluded?
- What is excluded for soil contamination or food illness?
On soil problems, see our soil guide; on animals, animals and livestock. A printable list with a comparison grid for two quotes is available as Insurance Questions for Gardens and Farms (PDF).
Frequently asked questions
Do community gardens need insurance?
No federal law requires it. A landowner, a city license or a lease often does, and you carry real risk without it. Pittsburgh’s adopt-a-lot lease, for example, requires insurance.
Does the Volunteer Protection Act protect my organization?
No. It protects the individual volunteer, and the statute says it does not affect the organization’s own liability.
Can a landowner be sued if someone is hurt in a garden on their land?
Possibly. Some states limit that liability (Texas has a community garden statute with a sign requirement), but the protection depends on the state and its conditions.
Do I need workers’ compensation for volunteers?
In many places not, but it depends on your state and on whether volunteers are really employees. Alaska is one state where nonprofits are not required to cover volunteers; others differ.
Is a waiver enough?
A signed waiver is a tool, not a guarantee. Courts decide whether it is enforceable under your state’s law, so do not treat it as a replacement for insurance.
How much does insurance cost?
We do not quote prices. They depend on your location, size, activities and insurer, so ask for written quotes.
Official sources
- Volunteer Protection Act of 1997, 42 U.S.C. §§ 14503 and 14505
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 75.0025 (added by H.B. 262, 2015)
- Oregon Revised Statutes § 105.688
- Alaska Department of Labor and Workforce Development, Workers’ Compensation: volunteers (page updated November 10, 2025)